Results of a system stricken by incompetence

SA’s longest-serving political columnist, William Saunderson-Meyer, expands on his latest op-ed the place he argued that Eskom-related energy cuts are a sideshow in contrast along with his homeland’s ever-escalating crime charge. The rationale for surging malfeasance, he believes, is apparent: the legal justice system – from policing to the courts via to prisons – is an ocean of incompetence with zero penalties. Fixing it will likely be a long-term challenge, and much more tough than merely replicating the Western Cape LEAP system (as Gauteng has been discovering of late….). WSM spoke to Alec Hogg of BizNews.

Watch right here

Related timestamps from the interview

  • 00:38 – William Saunderson-Meyer on his latest op-ed Eskom’s a sideshow in comparison with collapse of SAPS and NPA
  • 04:31 – WSM on the results of reliance on non-public policing
  • 10:32 – On the failures of the Nationwide Prosecuting Authority
  • 15:17 – On Shamila Batohi failing to fulfill expectations
  • 17:52 – On Markus Jooste’s possible lack of concern over being prosecuted
  • 18:46 – On whether or not or not the legal justice system could be mounted

Hear right here

Excerpts from the interview

William Saunderson-Meyer on the Western Cape’s LEAP system and Gauteng’s efforts to duplicate it

Premier Panyaza Lesufi has launched his personal model of LEAP, [the Gauteng Crime Prevention Wardens who are] relatively sinisterly now being referred to within the media because the Amapanyaza: which principally [means] Panyaza’s males, Panyaza’s gang [or] Panyaza’s warriors. Neighborhood policing, specialists agree is important. And one of many failures, other than the crime intelligence failure of the South African police companies, has been its incapacity to supply neighborhood companies. [This] is why one has vigilante teams going round and meting out swift and brutal justice which nearly unanimously meets with approval on social media. It’s a sign of the state of siege that many individuals stay in, particularly within the poorer communities the place they don’t have [the] 24 hour electrical energy that’s supplied to cupboard ministers, they don’t have blue gentle brigades taking care of them, and so they don’t have non-public safety taking care of them. So LEAP is a good thought, but it surely actually does rely [on] the way it’s carried out and we don’t know but how the Amapanyaza are going to function.

Learn extra: Eskom pales compared to downfall of SAPS and NPA – Saunderson-Meyer

What does Lesufi need? Is that this only a self-importance challenge or is it a step ahead? It’d be actually nice if he manages to scale back crime, but it surely’s not an answer. There must be oversight. No matter occurs on the bottom, we have to have a functioning police service. And never solely a functioning police service, [because] it’s completely pointless having the police arrest folks after which the prosecutors are unable to jail them. After which, after all, when they’re jailed, they they will stick a corpse within the mattress and disappear with out anybody noticing. It’s a structural decay that strikes proper from the policing to [the] prisoning level.

Learn extra: One can solely be amused by Gauteng’s new ‘crime prevention’ wardens – Ivo Vegter

WSM on the failures of the Nationwide Prosecuting Authority to place criminals behind bars

When you could have [13 or 14%] profitable prosecutions, how can Shamila Batohi sit in that job and never stroll out the door and say to the President, I’m sorry, I’ve failed abysmally. And she or he has failed abysmally! She’s been given 5 years to kind out what she known as the home burning down. Thus far, her contribution to the home burning down is to throw a cup of tea on it. She has 9 key prosecutions, seminal she calls them. – I consider them as nominal relatively than seminal. [So] she has 9 key prosecutions: the primary one was dismissed two weeks in the past, however the choose known as it a comedy of errors [and] she was scathing in her evaluation of it. Now, [the] NPA goes to attraction that, and they’re interesting it completely out of self-importance, not as a result of there’s a hope in hell of them succeeding within the attraction court docket. However [at] each stage, the failures are tied to lack of accountability. No society can function with out folks taking accountability for what they’re alleged to be doing and [being] punished in some type for failing to take action. And we’re a rustic the place there’s no accountability. That’s why we’ve got vigilantes. That’s why we’ve got such a lawless society. [It] is as a result of there’s by no means any accountability. 

Learn extra: Ian Cameron – Anticipating SAPS success is like believing a donkey can win Durban July

On if the failing legal justice system could be rectified

It turns into increasingly tough to reverse [the failing criminal justice system] as a result of there are increasingly issues to reverse. So the place one has a rot initially at both the decrease finish or the highest finish of an organisation, one now has a pervasive rot. How do how does a police officer not even be embarrassed to be sitting in a automobile with a gang chief and never fear about what the results of that will be? They haven’t any fear as a result of the corruption [and] the destruction of the fibre and the backbone of these organisations is nearly full. So it’s like all medical drawback: the longer we delay the therapy, the much less probably the success and the extra traumatic the therapy. So, sure, it may be circled. Societies can survive. Zimbabwe survives [for example], there are various folks in Zimbabwe who stay good lives. However can a society flourish? Can we flourish? Not within the rapid time period. So we’re 5 to 10 years to select up the items.

(Visited 41 instances, 41 visits in the present day)

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles